Tuesday, August 14, 2012

Drinking Free and Clean Water - History and Place

I'm really excited about an idea --> a drinking fountain in downtown Los Angeles, a sculptural piece designed to acknowledge the city's fundamental indebtedness to the Eastern Sierra.

On the theme of indebtedness, the great thing about water fountains is that they're free -- people will not merely experience the art of the fountain, not merely "get the message" of the presentation, but the very act of drinking transfers something external to something internal. People will directly internalize the gift of water from the Eastern Sierra.

Some background. I've been helping a local drinking water activist, Evelyn Wendel, jump-start her new organization: WeTap. Her first accomplishment has been the creation of an Android app that locates public drinking fountains. (See this recent Good Magazine.) Her objective is to resurrect drinking fountains in schools and parks and other public places thereby helping Angelenos, and children in particular, kick the corporate plastic water habit. (The people of Los Angeles waste many millions of dollars each year on plastic water bottles. As you may know, these bottles clutter our landfills. The act of trucking and stacking and refrigerating bottled water is carbon intensive, and contributes significantly to warming the planet. Last, the plastic bottles themselves contains phthalates, a toxin that can leach into the water. And Angelenos go through this effort when our existing water supply -- thanks to the Eastern Sierra -- is some of the best in the world.)

Last Saturday, I spent a four hours with Evelyn and others in a strategy meeting. Sitting in the conference room the various threads of my work synthesized into an "ah ha" moment. I was not merely thinking about the need to highlight drinking fountains, I was also thinking about the need for LADWP to have customers trust the quality of its water. There was also my work on climate change to limit greenhouse gas emissions. And, of course, I thought about the Chora Council objectives.

Just as CicLAvia accomplished multiple objectives in a single effort, so too could a smart and beautiful drinking fountain be a win-win-win-win for the people of Los Angeles and Owens Valley.

In fact, beautiful and smart drinking fountain sculptures could reconnect Angelenos with the multiple communities that supply its lifeblood. There could be a Mt. Whitney like granite drinking fountain at City Hall or La Placita. An Owens Gorge drinking fountain in Westwood. A Sequoia drinking fountain on Hollywood Blvd. A Grand Canyon drinking fountain at Ports O'Call in in San Pedro. (Or we could go dark and create drinking fountains out of used Crystal Geyser bottles, or in the shape of uranium mill-tailing mounds.)

I would like to see Los Angeles take a page from that other great Mediterranean city -- Rome -- where public fountains are identified with the city. These civic monuments also serve a social purpose as a gathering space. And in these times of constricting budgets, water fountains serve multiple purposes. It's public art made “legit” because of its utility.

But, pragmatically, for the 100 year commemoration, I think we can start with one (1) drinking fountain. If it works -- we can build more.

I've talked with Rec and Parks Jennie Carreon De Lacey who has offered to give a tour of the water fountain on the South Lawn of City Hall Park (a historical monument), but there is no fountain on the north lawn.

Water Advocate

Hello,
Tricia Watts, founder of ecoartspace, has suggested that Lloyd Carter, a San Joaquin Valley-based water historian/advocate/lawyer may be of interest to us. Although there is not a direct relationship between the centenary and the San Joaquin Valley, this may be useful FYI. Lloyd's website is http://www.lloydgcarter.com. And here's his bio: 

"Lloyd G. Carter, President of the California Save Our Streams Council, was a reporter for United Press International and the Fresno Bee from 1969 to 1990 covering water and agriculture issues in the San Joaquin Valley. He won several statewide journalism awards in 1985 for his coverage of the agricultural drainage water poisoning of the Kesterson National Wildlife Refuge. He graduated from San Joaquin College of Law in 1994 and now works as an appellate attorney for the California Attorney General‘s Office, Criminal Division. He formerly served as water law instructor at San Joaquin College of Law."

Sunday, August 12, 2012

Dear Kathy and Bill,
I like both of your ideas--an edition of Boom to be published at Stanford (?) and  a radio show that would allow programming to be "live time" while driving up the 395--fantastic ideas.....
Can each of you develop these ideas--Bill, you say you would be glad to work with your colleague on this--be in touch with us about this---I'd love to see it happen. What and how would you recommend the Studio do to make this happen.
Similarly, Kathy, do you have radio programming experience or people you could talk to to make this happen. Does anyone else on the Council have any thoughts on this. I think it's a brilliant idea-
Lauren

Saturday, August 11, 2012

New Idea

What about a radio station?  This could serve as a venue to broadcast some of the other programs and lectures being proposed and could especially be a welcome change from the lack of radio programming available while traveling up Highway 395. 

Wednesday, August 8, 2012

LA Noria prototype


Additional Imagery - Siempre Agua



Additional Imagery - Siempre Agua



Siempre Agua - LA Noria


Drawing by Lauren Bon

Hi Everyone,
I wanted to invite you all to a community open house we are having at Metabolic Studio tomorrow, August 9th from 6pm - 8pm.  Lauren and team will be sharing with the community about Siempre Agua, a metabolic sculpture that Lauren and the studio are designing and building to commemorate the centenary of the LA aqueduct.
Siempre Agua will bend the Los Angeles River and deliver water to the planned wetlands at the downtown Historic State Park.  This will be the first water wheel connected directly to the Los Angeles River in 135 years and will open on November 5, 2013.

Below is more information about the work to give you more background and details.  I know it's a little late notice but we would love to have you join us tomorrow if you can make it!

John




Siempre Agua

A Tunnel – Zanja Madre

A Water Wheel – LA Noria

&

A Wetland – The Delta of Mt. Whitney



Siempre Agua is a metabolic sculpture by Lauren Bon and Metabolic Studio consisting of an aqueduct diverting water from the Los Angeles River, a water wheel to lift it, and a wetland to treat and store it for beneficial use.  Ms. Bon has been at work over the last seven years to reintegrate Los Angeles with the source of its water in the historic center of the City.  Now, to commemorate the 100th anniversary of the opening of the Los Angeles Aqueduct, Ms. Bon will relate the LA River back into the heart of the City and in doing so, provide water to the Los Angeles State Historic Park and the City. Siempre Agua will help set a new Los Angeles River agenda for the next one hundred years and will give our City an icon for the new era.

Once completed, Los Angeles River water will be diverted through the channel walls of the Los Angeles River to a subterranean 72-inch diameter tunnel bored 30 feet below ground surface.  This side-channel will deliver water to an approximately 60-foot tall water wheel, half above ground and half below.  The water wheel, LA Noria, will be located on property owned by the Metropolitan Transportation Authority, between the River and the State Park, immediately south of the North Broadway Bridge. Of special significance, the project location is near the sites of several historic water wheels that operated in the mid 19th century to deliver water to the Pueblo de Los Angeles. Stylistically, LA Noria will be modeled after its predecessor from the 1860’s to evoke a sense of the history of this site.

During normal operations LA Noria will be powered by the River itself, to lift and deliver water to a small riparian area and 2-acre wetland on the Historic State Park property.  Water drawn from the wetland will be disinfected using ultra-violet light and distributed for non-potable uses within, and surrounding, the State Park.  Siempre Agua will ultimately off-set annual water demands totaling approximately 80 acre-feet, saving over $101,000 each year in water costs, increasing at a rate of 2.5% per year.



LA Water Wheel Location History

  1. 1854. City Council. At the toma just north of what is now the Broadway Bridge. This was the only wheel to take water directly from the River. The Wikipedia map of the zanja madre has the wheel exactly at the site of La Noria, but most accounts place it to the north. The wheel was washed out twice during winter floods, and after the heavy flood of 1867-68, it was not rebuilt. This was a noria-type wheel.
2.     1855. Abel Stearns. Water-powered flour mill. While I originally pegged the location at the southwest corner of the State Park, subsequent research determined that the location was in what is now the State Park --- directly across the street from Nick’s Café. This was what at the time was probably called a “molino” since it was used to power machinery. This was the first industrial use of a water wheel in Los Angeles.

3.     1857. Oscar Macy. Public bath house. Noria-type water wheel lifted water from the zanja to a tank that stored water for hot and cold baths. The wheel was located at the northwest corner of Alameda and Bath Street. Bath Street at the time was the northerly extension of what is now Main Street, just past the plaza.

4.     1860. W. H. Perry. A molino wheel, this was used to power equipment at Mr. Perry’s cabinet shop which was located at the northwest corner of what is now Main Street and Arcadia Street.

5.     1861. William Dryden. A noria in the zanja madre near Main and Alameda Streets (area known as Abila Springs). Water was lifted from the springs to a flume that carried it to a reservoir in the middle of the plaza. It was sold as a “pure water” alternative to water from the zanja madre, which was not so hygienic by virtue of human bathing, clothes washing and the dumping of sewage and animal carcasses into it. This wheel had 32 buckets, each carrying 4 and ½ gallons. It made two revolutions per minute, lifting 256 gallons per minute or 15,360 gallons per hour. It was built by W.H. Perry’s cabinet shop.

5A. 1862. William Dryden.  Water wheel #5 was moved to the junction of Marchessault and Alameda Streets. Marchessault no longer exists but if it did, it would be the street that is the northern boundary of the plaza heading due east across Alameda through what is now Union Station. Marchessault was a two-term Mayor who got into the water pipe and distribution business. Widespread complaints about broken pipes and muddy water, combined with the financial stress of an under-subscribed water system doubtless led to his suicide in Council chambers. A plaque is dedicated to him in the plaza.

6.     1863. Jean Sainsevain. In the zanja madre at the foot of Solano Canyon. Built in San Francisco and reassembled in Los Angeles, this noria had a diameter of 40 feet, making it the tallest structure in the city at the time. The paddles were six feet wide by two feet high and were about four feet apart. Buckets fastened to each paddle had a capacity of 15 gallons. Water running through a flume raised the water to a height of 36 feet to another flume that in turn carried the water to a reservoir Sainsevain built north of the old Catholic cemetery   

7.     1868. LA Waterworks Company. This noria is identifed on the 1868 map we have (seen north and east of the Catholic cemetery, which is marked with a † on the figure). The cemetery, by the way, was relocated to east Whittier Boulevard in 1930, although it is likely many bodies were left behind. Cathedral High School now sits on the site.

8.     1878. Thomas Leahy. On Alameda Street between 7th and 8th Streets. This noria lifted water from the zanja to irrigate Mr. Leahy’s vineyard. We have a photo of this one.
9.     Circa 1890. Vejan Ranch. On Washington Street near Hooper Avenue. Water was lifted from the zanja to a water tank. Water from this noria was periodically released from the tank to irrigate orchards. We have a photo of this one. 

10.  Circa 1900. A noria on South Alameda near Washington Boulevard. Water was lifted from the zanja to two large wooden barrels on top of wooden supports. Water was periodically released to irrigate what appears to be an orchard. We have a photo of this one. 

11.  2013. LA Noria. Just south of the Broadway Bridge between the LA River and the State Park. Designed by artist Lauren Bon, this wheel will lift water diverted from the river and convey it by flume or pipeline to a treatment wetlands at the park and from there distributed through the park for irrigation. LA Noria is a functioning art work that for the first time since concretization bends the river back towards the City and reconnects the river to the land.  



Monday, August 6, 2012

A proposal from the Eastern California Museum

Hello everyone,

I'd like to share a proposal from the ECM for marking the Aqueduct centenary. It outlines film and speaker series, (the former with Chris Langley + the Lone Pine Film Museum), along with stimulation of a network of local organizations and support for their efforts to mark the anniversary.

Enjoy!
Jan

Aug 3, 2012
Letter of Inquiry to Bridget K. Kelley, M.P.H., Program Officer, Janet Owen Driggs, Lauren Bon and the Metabolic Studio regarding grant funding for the Eastern California Museum

The Eastern California Museum in partnership with its non-profit fundraising organization, the Friends of the Eastern California Museum, would like the Metabolic Studio/Annenberg Foundation to consider this proposal for a $20,000 grant that will be used to plan, coordinate, create and produce a year-long series of events and programs in 2013 to commemorate the 100th anniversary of the completion of the Los Angeles Aqueduct.

The opening of the LA Aqueduct in 1913 was a defining moment in the history of the Owens Valley, the City of Los Angeles, the State of California and the American West. The Aqueduct has been a constant thread woven through life in the Owens Valley since a champagne shower at the Aqueduct Intake was followed by strong arms opening the gates on Feb. 13, 1913, and sending the Owens River coursing more than 200 miles south to Los Angeles.

This seminal event will be the focus of the Eastern California Museum’s programs, exhibits and collaborative partnerships during 2013. The Museum will install a photo exhibit that explores all aspects of the construction of the LA Aqueduct. As is typical with the Museum’s exhibits, the costs associated with creating and installing the exhibit will be funded exclusively by the Friends of the Eastern California Museum. Museum staff will research and curate the exhibit.

To supplement and support the exhibit, the Museum has outlined an impressive schedule of lectures, talks, programs, tours, and a Film Series related to the history and impact of the LA Aqueduct. In addition to hosting its own events, the Museum will facilitate and collaborate with other groups and organizations that are also hosting or creating programs and events related to the Aqueduct’s anniversary. The Museum will assume a leadership role to help other organizations craft a dynamic, individualistic array of events and programs about the LA Aqueduct and how the impacts created by that singular engineering feat are still rippling through the Eastern Sierra from Mono Lake to Mojave.

The grant funding being requested would be devoted to programming and collaboration. The following is the budget and explanation of the Museum’s multi-faceted plan for commemorating the LA Aqueduct’s Centennial.

$4,500 – ECM Staff Expenses related to production and hosting of events and programs and collaborating with other organizations. Funding will help pay for the cost of museum staffs’ time spent to coordinate museum-hosted events and also attend the events. There are potentially more than 20 museums and Owens Valley Tribes participating in the Eastern Sierra Cultural Heritage Alliance, and another half dozen non-profits which could be doing some sort of event or program related to the LA Aqueduct. Grant funds would pay for travel expenses (not time) so the Museum Director can meet in person with these groups’ board of directors (ESCHA, Friends of the Inyo, The Los Angeles Department of Water and Power, the Native Plant Society, Owens Valley Committee, Metabolic Studio, Mono Lake Committee, local chambers of commerce, etc.) to offer the Museum’s assistance as a “clearinghouse” for coordinating events and programs. That would entail creating a “master calendar” listing all LA Aqueduct or water related programs or events and making the calendar available electronically and in print; providing historic information and photos to publicize events; and brainstorming ways to improve or enhance individual events or collaborative efforts.

$500 – Provide groups, organizations and businesses with historic photos for promotion and publicity purposes at no cost from the Museum’s collection. The photos could be used in posters or online to advertise a group’s event or program, or could be used as part of the program or hand-out at the event. The Museum’s standard fee for photo reprints is $10 per photo, and $20 per hour for research, if needed. 

$3,000 – Create a “logo” and unique graphics to identify the Museum’s LA Aqueduct Anniversary events and pay for posters, print and radio advertising. The design theme/logo will provide an easily identifiable and unifying visual element for all print and electronic material used to promote the Museum’s Exhibit, speaker series, film series, events and tours. The “master” calendar would be reproduced at least 3 times during the year, be printed and distributed as a poster, run as a print ad, and offered as an electronic document to organizations and groups for posting on web pages, social media, etc.

$3,000 -- The Owens Valley Water Film Series. In cooperation with Chris Langley and the Lone Pine Lone Pine Film History Museum, the Film Festival would feature 10 water-related films, ranging from “Chinatown” and “Rango” to documentaries on water-related issues. Grant funds would pay for the costs of acquiring films and rights, Film History Museum staff time, advertising and receptions for visiting documentary filmmakers who would be meeting with the public before the screening and holding panel discussions after the showing.

$3,000 – Speaker Series. The Museum would host speakers on a variety of water- and aqueduct-related topics. Grant funds would pay expenses for out-of-area speakers, advertising and reception costs prior to the event. Some potential speakers: John Walton, author of “Western Times and Water Wars” who has already been confirmed as the guest speaker at the FECM Annual Meeting; William Kahrl, author of  “Water and Power”;  Rebecca Fish Ewan, author of “A Land Between” (an eco-cultural history Owens Valley); Ross Stone or other Paiute Elders  – Water’s Place in Paiute Culture; Kim Stringfellow, California Voices of the LA Aqueduct; The Water Education Foundation – How LAA Fits into and Shapes a California Water Overview; Center for Land Use Interpretation, LAA and the Owens Valley Landscape; Greg James, Tony Rossman, Legal Roundtable -- featuring the attorneys who won the legal case for Inyo County over LADWP which resulted in the current Long Term Water Agreement, etc.; Marty Adams or Jim McDaniel LADWP Water Division: The Next 100 Years of Water  – Climate Change, Regulatory Hurdles, Environmental Challenges; Lauren Bon, “Silver and Water,” or a topic of her choice.

This list is preliminary, and other groups might want to host specific speakers; thus the need for collaboration and program coordination to try and ensure great programs are presented but not duplicated.    

$1,000 – Learning About Your Water. An educational, hands-on one-day science “camp” for young people, held at the Museum and led by Sharon Avey. The grant would pay for supplies and materials, plus a stipend for the instructor. Depending on popularity, there could be several “camp” days for different ages addressing different topics.

$3,000 -- Tours with Informational Brochures. The grant funds would pay for the design and printing costs for the two brochures (1,000 copies each).
            LA Aqueduct, Then and Now (brochure)  – The publication would feature historic photos next to current photos of still-functioning, iconic LAA structures or locations (The Intake, The Alabama Gates, power plants, spillway, etc.), and include Frequently Asked Questions and basic statistics and info about LAA.
            Historic Ranches and Silos -- The Ranch/Silo Tour will be in person; plus there would be a brochure to hand out during the tour and in the future at the Museum with historic photos and information on pioneer ranches and photos of current silos and ranches.

Administering the grant funds would be the Museum’s partner, the Friends of the Eastern California Museum, a 501(c)3 non-profit organization, whose mission is to support the programs and operations of the Eastern California Museum. The group also operates the Manzanar Bookstore as a cooperating association of the National Park Service at the nearby Manzanar National Historic Site.  Thus, the Friends have a bookkeeping system in place that can accommodate all financial requirements regarding administering, reporting and tracking the requested grant funds.

Similar to many public museums, the Eastern California Museum’s budget for exhibits and programming has been reduced to almost the bare minimum. The total budget from Inyo County for 2012-13 is approximately $215,000, most of which goes to funding for two full-time and one part time employee (with the Director also assigned non-museum related tasks for the county). 

The requested grant funding would provide the Museum with the resources to confidently undertake a rather ambitious, year-long programming and event schedule focusing on the 100th anniversary of the completion of the Los Angeles Aqueduct. The project outlined above would be the biggest, most comprehensive programming effort produced by the Eastern California Museum to support, enhance and expand upon a museum exhibit. The significance of the Los Angeles Aqueduct to the region’s history, its century of impacts on day-to-day life in the Owens Valley, and the repercussions it has created and will continue to create almost demand the type of reflection, education and perspective we hope will be provided by the multi-faceted program and event schedule proposed.

The Eastern California Museum and the Friends of the Eastern California Museum are grateful for the Metabolic Studio’s interest in helping the Museum and Friends present this important series of events and programs. By providing the resources to allow Museum staff to play a key role in collaborating and coordinating with other groups, this grant would also help to ensure the LA Aqueduct’s anniversary is addressed or acknowledged by a diverse group of organizations, which will truly make the anniversary a memorable event in the entire Owens Valley.        

Sincerely:

Jon Klusmire
Museum Services Administrator
Eastern California Museum





Thursday, August 2, 2012

Hi All,

Here's the list of people I'm currently working with to develop proposals:

Kim Abeles, LA artist, walk the aqueduct;
http://kimabeles.com/

VENUE, Geoff Manaugh and Nicole Twilley from Studio-X travel the aqueduct and conduct interviews and public events, assemble an archive for someone;
http://www.v-e-n-u-e.com/

Bill Deverell, USC/Huntington, series of public engagements;

David Benjamin & Soo-In Yang (aka The Living, New York), remote sensing & embedded sensors of and in the aqueduct (they have worked extensively in the Hudson River); http://www.thelivingnewyork.com/

UGLARWorks, LA community artists, murals & events?;
http://uglarworks.com/

I'm off to Australia the 5th through the 13th to work on projects, give a talk, etc.--then back for the remaining of the month.

Cheers,

Bill

Friday, July 27, 2012

Hi Kathy, et al,

Trying for a third time to post this comment. I like your ideas in that they're different from all the other contributions so far, yet mesh with everything!

Bill

Thursday, July 26, 2012

Owens Valley Contributions

I just want to run some ideas by all of you great minds to get input and ideas.

One idea involves mules, as you all know we are the Mule Capital of the World.  The aquaduct was built because of mule power.  You have probably seen some of the pictures of mule teams pulling huge equipment on the aquaduct job. Not just a 20 mule team, but 30 and 40 mule teams.  There is an old guy who learned how to work these large teams of mules and has taught a few younger people the art.  They are willing to put something together for the anniversary to draw attention to not only the history of the aquaduct, but alternative energy and hopefully start several other conversations.

A young, local man is interested in film making and originally came up, building on, the idea of  "100 conversations" to shoot a moving picture with 100 local individuals standing, one at a time somewhere along the aquaduct holding a card, or whiteboard with a short statement of their thought about the endeavor/situation.  This could be done with both Owens Valley and southern California people.  All he needed was film because he has the equipment.  When I asked what he could do if he had some funding to back him, he came up with all sorts of ideas to expand his original idea.

A third idea is coming from the group of young people on the Owens Valley reservations who created this video:
http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=ScwddpHfvQE
If the link doesn't work, just do a search on YouTube. It's called "Paya for the People."  Paya is our word for water.

Tuesday, July 24, 2012

Infrastructure for Intimate and Meaningful Conversations


One focus of my thinking has been creating the Infrastructure for Deep and Meaningful and Intimate Conversations throughout the region.  I'm talking to a number of resources, including the Ojai Foundation who has spawned several vehicles for the process of Council--a simple but extremely effective means of having people in small groups speak and listen to each other (one intention is to speak and listen from the heart). One of the vehicles, Council in Schools, is facilitating conversations including 12,000 school children a week throughout LA City. Another of the vehicles: The Center for Council Practice is supporting groups and organizations of all sorts in having Councils in community and work settings. They are working with groups as diverse as Transition Town, churches, synagogues, prisons.  They are able to convene conversations on specific topics and can also provide curriculum or content to create a foundation of shared understanding from which to start a conversation.  They have a network of dozens of trainers, who I believe can create a very large cadre of grassroots conversation leaders.  I believe they could scale their network to facilitate intimate conversations involving over a million people or more during our target time frame.

The Council methodology could be used to facilitate follow-up conversations by people who are exposed to any of the public events, expositions, etc.  I'm interested in pursuing this path because the methodology creates very rare and deep personal engagement and often leads both to ongoing conversations and a unique kind of community building.

A third link to the Ojai Foundation is Three Creeks Ranch in Lone Pine.  The ranch hosts very special retreats that deeply connect participants with the Nature of the Owens Valley and River--and themselves.  I have introduced several Metabolic Studio staff members to Three Creeks and its founder, Gigi Coyle.  I believe that it may be possible to work with Three Creeks and Gigi to host some very special conversations/retreats with people who have a significant impacts on the Owens and Los Angeles.

More on this as the possibility unfolds.

Conflict of Interest statement:  My wife is a trained/certified Council trainer.  As such, there is a chance that a program with Council in Schools or The Center for Council Practice might possibly involve her in some way, and since some of her involvement with Council includes compensated work, as well as volunteer work.

Roxanne Oguri, member of the Metabolic Studio staff, is a trained Council facilitator and could serve as a reference.

Offline but not off mission...

Aloha Chora Council Mates:

As I mentioned in the meeting, I'm off the grid: water, electricity, internet and cell, while doing some construction and vacation at Talking Peace Farm on the Big Island of Hawaii.  Harvesting our own rainwater and converting the sun's energy for a bit of electricity, has me living some of the implications of 100 years of aqueduct.  I'm only able to get an internet signal on rare occasions, so you won't hear much from me, nor me from you, until after August 10th.  I've just caught up on the posts...all good.  In the mean time, I'm thinking and taking notes...and probably will be writing off line for uploading when I get to the net.

I'll post one idea now, under separate cover.  Just wanted to connect and let you know that I'm alive and feeling connected even though you aren't hearing from me.

-Andy


Hi everybody! 
I finally got on the blog here in Lone Pine, thanks to a lot of help from Meredith, John and everybody else.  This is just a test.  I'll get back soon.

Sunday, July 22, 2012

Had a nice chat with Mike Woo today, and here are some notions that resonated with me: 1. Getting a sense of what related events/programming might be going on in the city: Maybe we should poll the various creative cultural orgs in town to see if they have programming related to the centennial they are planning. If so, be good to know. If not, then maybe we can see if they are interested in developing one, since there is still time to develop something, maybe by "hosting" a creative program, such as an artist working with them in a way that is consistent with the focus/methods/strengths of the org, or an exhibition or other program. For "maximum impact", large orgs maybe to poll/query include: MOCA, LACMA, Natural History Museum, Autry, Getty, Hammer... Other, smaller ones, equally important, include: Echo Park Film Center, Velaslavsay Panorama, Machine Projects, Telic, LACE, Lone Pine Movie History Museum, Studio for Southern California History, and others of course... Orgs already known to be doing something: DWP, CLUI, Cal Poly Pomona, Huntington (anything beside Bill Deverell's projects? They seem to be an important player in LA water history!), Eastern CA Museum (Independence), Metabolic, Arid Lands Institute, others? Maybe some other academic orgs would be involved too, hosting symposia, lectures, etc. USC, UCLA (Jon Christensen, head of the Bill Lane Center for the American West at Stanford University is moving to UCLA's Institute of the Environment and Sustainability, and is a great guy who may want to do stuff), Art Center, Cal Arts, Sciarc...I gather Barry Lehrman from Cal Poly has been funded by Metabolic to do a potential host of programs. We'd need to keep in the loop about what he intends to do so we are not redundant. And the Arid Lands Institute also, along lines that Janet outlined, and the Huntington, as Bill Fox has described Bill Deverell's intentions, which sound good. 2. If this is a direction to head in, then there is the idea of a central coordinating organization/entity, like the "Pacific Standard Time" entity, maybe a "Watershed: 100 years of the LA Aqueduct" festival, cultural initiative, whatever we call it, which maybe should be independent, but have a full time figurehead person to help manage, promote, and coordinate these various programs, a kind of overall ubur-curator and cross-institutional connective tissue person, an MC, a humanities person... Lawrence Weschler comes to mind as someone who might be good at this, someone with LA roots, and someone we know... Anyhow, this is a kind of "centralized" notion for all this. We can do it in a decentralized way too of course, where all of us suggest disparate things that would happen in their own way, which could work too... Either way, I will continue working on my list of interesting artists and creative people to possibly pair with a potential org, for a potential project, at a potential place, and time, and post that when I have it ready...

Tuesday, July 17, 2012

Hey Matt, and All,

Yes, younger artists! I'll be talking soon with the ULGAR folks, but they're already older (?) than some people you might talk with. I'll be very curious who you have in mind. And Matt, if any of what you propose has implications for archives here, let me know. I'll be keeping my eyes open for a project that we could collect and then show.

As far as Geoff/Nicky as directors of any effort--I suspect they're up to their eyeballs in stuff, but this is post-VENUE, so maybe they'd be open.

Just off the phone with Bill Deverell who has in mind a suite of conversations he would coordinate through a mix of venues--Zocalo (yes, they're nonprofit), the downtown public library, the Huntington, and one more organization. They idea is a different theme or idea for each place, and a different audience. He's very interested in reaching high school kids, and is developing some undergraduate materials about LA and rivers into which all of this could flow (ahem) as well. Very good synergies. He's also keen to talk to Geoff and Nicky and see if there's a collaborative effort possible there, too. (They've been trying to get together for some time, so this is a great excuse, a side benefit to Lauren's creative philanthropy).

Onward...

Bill

Friday, July 13, 2012

Hello there all! Sorry for the tardiness, been on family duty “back east”, and then had problems logging in… Good thoughts so far all around. Glad to hear that some of the people I was going to suggest have already been mentioned, and I would like to second them for inclusion/support, especially: Hadley (and Peter) Arnold of the Arid Land Institute; Kim Stringfellow’s Owens Valley project; Manaugh/Twilley/VENUE; John Spiak/Matthew Moore/Central Arizona Project (Though the latter is not the LA Aqueduct, it does seem to me not a bad thing to “branch out” a bit, so long as the majority of the programming is on subject.) There are many artists working with water/water scarcity who could be drawn in (including many well-known photographers who have worked on water issues (whom Bill Fox knows well too), including Burtynsky (whose water project is no doubt going to be a blockbuster)) but I think its also important to also consider the “needy” artists (young, and old) who work hard and rarely get paid (and who usually spend it all on supplies even when they do) who are doing interesting water projects, who could be commissioned to do something larger and site-specific scale. Many of the “artist” people we might consider are part of an upcoming exhibition and a long-ongoing project described at: www.watercalifornia.org This is a good sampling of some “water artists” in the state. I may end up recommending several of these people for projects as part of this “water festival” notion, along with some others. I could imagine Chora recommending supporting a few such creative (and attention-getting?) projects like this, under some kind of thematic “festival” or “celebration” of water in LA and (lack of) in the Owens Valley. I could imagine it as having a few sites in LA and maybe a few in the Valley. People can connect to them at events on weekends around the anniversary. Of course there probably should be some kind of tour, bringing LA people up to Owens (and Owens people to LA) and maybe people like Kim Stringfellow or Geoff Manaugh or Barry Lehrman and Mike Prather (of Lone Pine) and DWP officials can be part of it. Also, the CLUI has been planning a show about the POWER side of DWP for a number of years, and we will be doing it as part of the Nov 2013 “celebration”. It will be an overview of the system, focusing on the “downstream” end (the users and distribution), though we will be making connections to the “upstream” end too (meaning the sources of power – Intermountain, Bonneville, etc.). And in general, it makes me wonder more, as came up in our meeting, if there should be some kind of overarching programming entity that could be created to manage the “festival” or whatever its called, some kind of “There it Was - Took It! Events” committee. Maybe that’s us? Maybe we should suggest appointing/hiring a director for all this? (Any volunteers?) Maybe this is what Geoff/Nicky would do?

Manaugh & Twilley

I had a terrific conversation this morning with Geoff Manaugh and Nicky Twilley--they were brimming with ideas about following the aquaduct by foot, car, and airplane--and envisioning what it would be without water, comparing it to other aquaducts around the world, and more.

Here's a note, though--the first question they had was whether or not they could choose CLUI as their partner organization. I explained that the program was designed to bring in nonprofits new to this particular mix of endeavors, so they'll seek out other possibilities.

Other names that have surface from the Museum staff here include Jennifer Steinkamp, Chris Drury in the UK, and David Benjamin from NYC. I'm a little wary of trying to involve artists from far away, however. Any thoughts?

Bill

Tuesday, July 10, 2012

Hello Chora Council,
As promised, here are two more of the thoughts regarding programming toward one hundred years of water that I've gathered on recent peregrinations around the topic:


The first hails from John Spiak, Director and Curator, Grand Central Art Center, Santa Ana. John, who recently joined GCAC from the art museum at Arizona State University, has expressed interest in bringing Matthew Moore to Santa Ana to focus on the LA Aqueduct as an artist in residence. Matt recently undertook a scrutiny of the Central Arizona Project, a 336 mile aqueduct that delivers Colorado River water into central and Southern Arizona. Again, please feel free to contact John if you would like to explore this idea further, or, should you prefer, I'm happy to make an introduction. (jspiak@Exchange.FULLERTON.EDU)


The second is from Chris Austin, aka Maven, founder and keeper of the Aquafornia website, an excellent aggregator of water-related news and information, which is now owned by the Water Education Foundation. Chris has an older project on her personal website titled "The Los Angeles Aqueduct in pictures: From Mono Lake to Southern California". She is pondering ideas for the 100th anniversary but thinks that one might entail an overhaul of the "Aqueduct in pictures", using the Eastern California Museum archive as a source. (Chris Austin: chrisaustin@mavensmanor.com)

Thanks Bill

Thanks to Bill Fox for reminding me about the Arid Lands Institute.

Crazy thing -- I've never met Hadley or Peter Arnold. So I've set up a lunch meeting w/ them at Musso and Frank's in August.

Jonathan
Hi All,

Bill Deverell and I are scheduling a phone call, and I've notes out to Km Abeles and the VENUE folks. A group that interests me is UGLAR--who in an earlier incarnation did a terrific project on the LA River--the Ulysses Guide to the Los Angeles River--that PMCA showed in 2010 (there's a book of the same title). Haven't contacted them yet.

I'm also thinking about the photographer Edward Burtynsky, as he's embarked on a huge project about water. The digital artist Jennifer Steinkamp at UCLA is another interesting thought--but I think I need to keep the number of invitations smaller rather than larger.

All reactions solicited.

Bill
I'm doing an interview with Kim Stringfellow this Monday. Her project is right up our alley.  
Kim Stringfellow is an independent artist/producer who is partnering with the Friends of the Eastern California Museum to produce an audio tour project funded California Council for the Humanities California Story Fund Initiative titled, "There It Is—Take It!.” This audio project will take the form of a free, self-guided car audio tour where listeners can navigate important historical and other sites of interest concerning the Los Angeles Aqueduct system along U.S. Route 395 in scenic Owens Valley. Author and UC Davis Professor, John Walton, author of "Western Times and Water Wars," is the contributing humanities expert for this project which is scheduled for release in late fall 2012.
There It Is—Take It is a web‐based multimedia presentation featuring a free, downloadable car audio tour examining the controversial social, political, and environmental history of the Los Angeles Aqueduct. The audio tour juxtaposes stories of the aqueduct from multiple perspectives and viewpoints through the voices of cultural geographers, historians, biologists, activists, environmentalists, native speakers, and residents from both Los Angeles and the Owens Valley. The hour and a half‐long program seeks to shed light on the mutual past, present, and possible future of Los Angeles and Owens Valley—centered around its complicated and intertwined water history. The project will illuminate the historic physical source of drinking water for the Los Angeles municipality while simultaneously revealing the complex relationship these two seemingly polar regions of California share through a sonically innovative aural program that educates the listener while experiencing scenic Owens Valley landscape firsthand along U.S. Route 395. This project will be designed for a variety of age groups and will include a forum for public discussion at the project’s web site.
Hi Everyone, Lauren wanted to share with the team a copy of the actual invite of the opening of the Aqueduct from 1913. I'll also send everyone a copy through email. Thanks, John
This entry is largely to test whether or not I'm being effective at posting at all! I"ve read most of what everyone has said so far and am excited by the beginning of the dialogue. Thank you Jonathan for pointing out that it might be a good idea to get a good and reliable scientific prediction on how global warming will effect the Eastern Sierras. Currently the ground water being removed from OValley is causing distress--very visibly in Independence where trees in town are not making it for lack of water--As a way to reveal our interdependence a study may be a good start!
Also I've asked John Yi to add onto this blog a copy of the invitation to the opening of the Museum at Exposition Park and how it was celebrated at the same time as the water from the Eastern Sierra's was brought into the San Fernando Valley.
Thanks
Lauren

Friday, July 6, 2012


Hello Chora Council,
You have outlined an interesting set of questions Mike, thank you. While they are for you all – the Council – and Lauren to address together, may I approach then tangentially, at least in regard to the consideration of "meaningful programming," by passing on a couple of leads I have pursued to date?"

As I described in our meeting, I have recently approached a few people who, along with their organizations, seem a strong bet to create "meaningful programming." They included Bill Deverell, Director, Huntington-USC Institute on California and the West; and Hadley Arnold, Co-Director of the Arid Lands Institute, Woodbury University.

Bill Fox has kindly agreed to pick up the thread with Bill Deverell, and will, I'm sure, share more as the conversation progresses. While Hadley outlined some initial programming ideas that I elucidate below. Should you find they pique your interest, please do contact Hadley directly (hadley.arnold@woodbury.edu), or I'm happy to do an email introduction if you prefer? 

(Alternatively please feel free to ignore this entirely -- I don't intend to direct your thinking, merely to be as transparent regarding the process to date as possible!)  

As this post is already looking rather long, I'll add further ideas and names in subsequent posts. 

Notes from a conversation with Hadley Arnold: 
•  If design innovation is about how design is taught, how do we rewrite the way
that the history of western landscape is taught? There’s a drylands way to tell 
the story that’s distinct.

•  Arid Lands Institute (ALI) is interested in designing the gravity fed city for the 
next 100 years. The Aqueduct is an example of gravity feed engineering + 
public architecture that wasn't taken to its full expressive potential.

•  We want to engage film, literature, and the visual arts as valid informers of 
the design process and integrate history/arts/humanities into the consideration 
of architecture around water to generate an imaginative, not just a 
proscriptive, voice. 

•  Both ‘fallowing’ and ‘harvesting’ are important to ALI. There is a lot of 
great material to collect – many ideas toward the gravity fed city, many that we 
have already gathered. We’d like to make the information lastingly available.

ALI's current thoughts re. programming around the centenary:
The following represents a sliding spectrum within which Hadley is thinking. Please know that she speaks on the subject with far greater eloquence than I am writing, and the budgets are very very approximate.)

·    Design Studio: (v. approx. $20.000). Focused around the following question or similar: “What would LA have to do to put not 20% but 80% of the water back into the Owens Lake?”

·    Public Lecture Series: (v. approx. $10,000). Considering, “How do we read the west?” + the layering of histories in OV and LA, with a focus including literature + film.

·    Design Competition: (v. approx. $40,000) (without book documentation). Along the lines of the competition that generated this year’s ALI conference (the one we attended with Jaime) but with the issue of “gravity fed design toward LA’s next 100 years”, the question “What would LA have to do to put not 20% but 80% of the water back into the Owens Lake?” or similar at its heart.

·    Pamphlet Suite: (v. approx. $60-80k): a suite of pamphlets or manuals, a future archeology of the gravity fed city, which has always been our central preoccupation. The suite would draw upon ALI’s archives, which are dying to be sifted, sorted, and communicated, and include histories and case studies, supplemented with the work of drylands designers locally, indigenously, and over the world.


Ahoy, All...

A quick note in between trips. I'll be talking with historian Bill Deverell at USC, Geoff Manaugh and Nicola Twilley of VENUE (http://www.v-e-n-u-e.com/), and LA artist Kim Abeles to start with. There's a group of local street artists who did a project on the LA River that was exhibited at the Pasadena Museum of California Art in 2010--I may be contacting them, as well.

Bill

Thursday, July 5, 2012

A very tantalizing puzzle

The Metabolic Studio has created a very tantalizing puzzle for us to address in a fairly short period of time.  In the aftermath of an Independence Day when I watched an episode of the HBO series "John Adams," prompting some ideas on the pros and cons of confederation and independence, here is a list of some questions which have started to pop up in my mind:


  1. What would we consider to be "meaningful programming"?  Some aspects could include:  (A) Does the outcome need to be lasting or enduring over a period of time?  Or could it be ephemeral and still be considered "meaningful"?  (B)  Does the outcome need to be broadly visible or accessible?  Or could it be "meaningful" if the outcome is not visible or accessible to a large audience?  (C)  Does the outcome need to generate participation (an active, not a passive, response)?  (D)  Should the outcome be characterized by some degree of "depth" or "impact" in order to be considered "meaningful"?
  2. How close should we hew to the theme of the LA Aqueduct centenary?  Or should we consider more elliptical references to water, land, and the environment (not referring specifically to the LA Aqueduct)?
  3. Should members of the Chora Council strive to develop some consensus about a small number of  relatively large grants which, in theory, might have a larger impact?  If yes, then can we start to develop a consensus about unifying concepts which might justify large grants?  On the other hand, should we be open to the possibility that the Chora Council will end up recommending a multitude of small grants?  Or should we move towards a hybrid of some large grants and a number of smaller grants?






Monday, July 2, 2012

The Next 100 Years . . .

I'm really taken by Lauren's vision of creating a new path forward in the relationship between Owens Valley and Los Angeles over the next hundred years.

To my thinking there are outside forces that will partly drive the relationship between Owens Valley and LA. One of those forces is climate change, and its potential impacts on Los Angeles and the Eastern Sierra.

My org recently helped the Mayor's office release the UCLA study on midcentury warming. In case you didn't see the articles, by 2041, downtown Los Angeles is predicted to have triple the number of extreme heat days; the Valley will experience quadruple the number.

Over the next few months my organization is helping UCLA release the next series of studies on LA's future climate. We're looking at future precipitation, hydrology, Santa Ana wind condition and coastal fog.

These studies together will suggest the range of LA's future climate impacts and offer hints about the region's future water demands. (And, of course, as an activist I believe we must use this info to drive civic investment in local water conservation, stormwater capture and water recycling.)

Again, LA's future water supply and demand are but two of those outside forces that will partially drive the relationship between the Eastern Sierra and LA.

Now the conundrum. There a mega hole in the data: we don't know how the Eastern Sierra will be changed by new climatic conditions. A couple years back LADWP hired TetraTech to write a study concerning the next 100 years of Eastern Sierra water supply -- I've previously forwarded the study to Metabolic Studio staff. However, according to climate scientists I know and respect, they see the TetraTech study as pure conjecture; their study failed to follow the simplest of standard climatological research procedures.


As we look to the next 100 years, it seems essential to me to have the best science available on the climate future of the Sierra Nevada Mountains.

I happen know the climate scientists -- the finest in the world -- that could downscale the two dozen valid global climate models and bring the Eastern Sierra's future into focus.

best ~

Jonathan Parfrey

Sunday, July 1, 2012

Hello Folks.  It was great to connect with all of you last week and get this brain trust storm in gear.  For my first post, I'm uploading an brief report out from a State legislative hearing on water that we hosted at TreePeople last month.  Lauren saw it and suggested I share it with y'all, so here it is along with her note:-----------

Dear Andy,

thank you for sending me this hearing on storm water and it's potential uses in LA, it's a comprehensive picture of what is being done and can be done! Please post this link to the google page that we will establish next week for the chora group---it brings up real people, projects and places to consider as part of our consideration to activate dialogue about one hundred years of the LA Aquaduct.
Thanks for all you do.
Lauren 
On Fri, Jun 1, 2012 at 6:07 PM, Andy Lipkis <alipkis@treepeople.org> wrote:

Dear Stormwater Enthusiasts,

After reflecting on the hope and inspiration created by the California State Assembly Hearing on the “Future of Stormwater:  Capture, Store and Supply,” I’m writing to thank you for your participation and expression of interest and support.

Over 140 people attended, creating a standing room-only crowd of some of Southern California’s foremost leaders in stormwater harvesting.  The collective testimony painted a clear picture of how capturing local rainwater can become both a significant component of Southern California’s water supply, and a substantial driver for revitalizing its economy.

Assemblyman Jose Solorio, who both convened and presided over the event, expressed his enthusiasm for what he learned at the hearing, which adds impetus to his efforts to pass legislation enabling significant expansion of rainwater harvesting.

TreePeople was honored to host this hearing.  In his opening remarks, LA County Supervisor Zev Yaroslavsky, an early and outspoken watershed advocate, noted the significance of the location in which we shared this moment, reminding the audience that for the past 20 years, TreePeople has been the hub of innovation in watershed management and rainwater harvesting technology development in Southern California.

My core message to the legislators was this: After 20 years of successful demonstration projects and pilot programs, it is now time for us to commit to full scale implementation. This is how to achieve the necessary economies of scale, and to more quickly adapt to growing water shortages and increasing costs of importing water.

Perhaps the most hopeful testimony came in the Success Stories panel, whose speakers documented demonstration projects and pilot programs that have proven to be effective and ready to grow to full scale.  It was thrilling to see the young people from Generation Water share their firsthand experience retrofitting landscapes in the pilot rain garden program, which was sponsored by the Department of Water and Power with TreePeople and Generation Water.  They were matched by small businessman Scott Mathers of Hey!Tanks LA who told how his contracting business grew into full-time installation of cisterns. He now has the equivalent of 12 employees and sub-contractors.  His business is driven by demand from early adopters.

We have assembled all presentations from the hearing along with full video of the testimony, and invite you to share in the memories and inspiration by having a look here.  Even more important, please share these with your colleagues and friends.

Thank you again for your interest and participation.  Please stay tuned and we will keep you posted on further progress.

Sincerely,


Andy Lipkis
President and Founder
TreePeople