Thursday, September 6, 2012

Sorry for coming in late. I've been away all summer. After reading through this lively and thoughtful discussion, here are some belated thoughts. 

SUGGESTIONS
  • I would like to suggest symposia that ask larger questions about water, Owens Valley, and Los Angeles. For instance, there is a debate among economic historians about the impact of Mulholland's purchase of the land for the aqueduct. Many bemoan it as theft while others argue that the farmers who sold their land profited tremendously. We should also raise questions about the utility of putting water back into Owens Lake. Overall, very little is said about the value of Los Angeles. Should these projects simply lament the aqueduct, or should they also include celebrations of the way in which it made possible a cosmopolitan city?
  • Another question that has not been asked but ought to be addressed in discussions about the water crisis: which entities can and should be involved? Many have suggested projects that only the state or federal government could undertake, yet no mention is made that the aqueduct itself was a government project. Given its track record, can the public sector be trusted to address the water crisis? Can market forces do it? Should it be left to non-profits? Or is some combination of the three the only answer? The Environmental Defense Fund has led many discussions on this since the 1980s, when Tom Graff took over as president. The EDF should be involved in our events.
  • There is no mention of the global water crisis, and I think some effort could be made to integrate the discussions of Los Angeles and the Owens Valley with the world-wide water shortage that is growing ever more acute. 
  • I would like to propose a book of debates on the major issues involving not just water, Owens Valley, and Los Angeles, but also the global water crisis. 
  • Lori Fogarty, head of the Oakland Museum of California, is very interested both in partnering with Occidental College on our own water projects, as well as submitting a proposal to the Chora Council for the Museum's work. I asked her to write up a quick summary of their water-related projects and told her I would plead mea culpa, and beg for an extension so that she can submit a full proposal to Chora. She thinks she can have one ready by early next week. For now, here is what she wrote about the museum's projects:
The Oakland Museum of California is the only museum in the state to explore the natural and cultural landscape of California, with the largest and most complete collection of California's art, history, and natural sciences.  In the coming years, the Museum has a number of projects that relate to water issues in the state.  In fall 2013, the Museum will present the first major exhibition on the history of the San Francisco Bay, exploring the hybrid landscape of the Bay as the defining natural characteristic of the region, but as one that has been defined by human habitation for the past 5,000 years.  While the exhibition itself is about a body of water, one particular component may be of particular interest.  The Museum is currently in discussion with the Center for Land Use Interpretation (CLUI) on a commissioned film that would trace the "edge" of the Bay from a low altitude, investigating the incredible diversity of the Bay's edge and the vast expanse that comprises its shoreline.  While planned for the exhibition, it could also be re-purposed for other platforms, particularly the Web or Web applications that could allow people to even experience the film at or on the Bay itself.

Also in 2013, the Museum will open the Gallery of California Natural Sciences, a 30,000 permanent exhibit that explores California as a biodiversity "hotspot," investigating both its extraordinary natural biodiversity as well as the environment under threat and how communities throughout the state are responding through stewardship and conservation efforts.  The Gallery will include seven real places in California, all of which incorporate a strong water story.  In particular, two sections of the gallery will feature locations in Southern California.  The Tehachapis, a mountainous hub where the Mojave Desert, San Joaquin Valley, Sierra Nevadas, Great Basin, and Coast Ranges all meet, is a key area of ecological evolution. Impressive dioramas will reveal how diverse species, including Tule elk and mountain lions, coexist in this unique region of many habitats.  Coachella Valley is a desert of palm trees and sand dunes. Visitors will learn how uniquely Californian species thrive in this arid environment; they will also see how the human population taxes the scarce water supply and how Native American communities are working to preserve the land.
Finally, just in the early planning stages, is an exhibition we are considering of photographs by David Maisel focused on a body of work known as "The Lake Project."  In this project, Maisel takes aerial photographs of the the Owens Valley.  As described on his Web site: "Beginning in 1913, the now infamous Los Angeles reclamation project effectively diverted water from Owens Valley to the Los Angeles Aqeuduct, providing a substantial amount of the city's water supply.  By 1926, the lower Owens River and Owens Lake were essentially depleted of water, leaving a vast exposed salt flat with unusually concentrated mineral levels and extremely vulnerable topsoil.  The situation has been exacerbated by the fierce winds that sweep through the valley and dislodge carcinogenic particles from the lakebed, creating a pervasive dust cloud known as the Keeler fog.  The Owens Lake region, the largest source of particulate matter pollution in the United States, is now undergoing an EPA approved, state implemented plan to control the spread of this hazardous matter.  After decades of accelerated destruction, the ground is once again flooded, this time by EPA officials in an effort to diminish the toxic dust that settles in the soil, vegetation, and lungs of nearby inhabitants.  From the air, high above this damaged wasteland, the ground assembles itself into something spectacular and horrifying.  This is what David Maisel sees through his camera, a contemporary version of the sublime."

We would be happy to put together proposals for any of these projects, if there is interest.


Jonathan Veitch, Occidental College

Wednesday, September 5, 2012

Grant proposal: Making an Eagle Rock median more water-wise

Dear colleagues:

I am forwarding a proposal from Tricia Robbins, Planning Deputy to L.A. City Councilmember Jose Huizar, who is proposing a grant to redesign and replant a median in the middle of a major street in the Eagle Rock area of Los Angeles, making the median a public showcase of water-wise landscaping and sustainable water use.  After getting feedback from me that her original proposal may entail too large a sum of money, Ms. Robbins subsequently indicated a willingness to scale her cost estimate down.

Best regards,
Michael



Here is Ms. Robbins's initial discussion of the Eagle Rock median redesign project:


In a nutshell, our proposal focuses on making medians within Council District 14 waterwise.


Arising from the City of Los Angeles median maintenance cuts during the FY 2010/2011 budget, medians in certain sections of the City were affected while others were not. The medians in CD 14, in Eagle Rock, Glassell Park, and El Sereno, slowly became overgrown, brown and unkempt.

Councilmember Jose Huizar, in response to resident requests to create sustainable medians that could survive future budget cuts, created a Median Advisory Committee to create a long-term plan to for the eventual re-landscaping of the medians.  The committee focused on the use of native and drought-resistant plants, water and power conservation, and green technologies to improve medians and reduce maintenance.

With the assistance of our office, representatives from the Bureau of Street Services and the Office of Community Beautification, and Public Works Commissioner Andrea Alarcon, and over a 12-month period, the volunteer Median Advisory Committee weighed all the concerns and issues and developed the attached plans and waterwise planting scheme for one median demonstration project in the Eagle Rock Area.

Tthe Bureau of Street Services has provided the following ballpark estimate to implement the proposed target median:

Base construction costs  $208,600
Installation cost on OT without overheads $312,900
Installation cost on straight time with full overheads $521,500.
 
They usually use the City Staff on straight time with full overheads when applying for grants.

The costs include:
a) Remove the existing landscape and irrigation system, including 7 (blind guess) trees and lawn,
b) Install 7 new trees, shrubs and ground cover,
c) new irrigation system,
d) cobble swale (which includes regrading from high point in the center of the median, to a low point in the center of the median).
e) Move on Costs (minimal)
f) 20% contingency
g) 25% Design, PM, CM, Survey
 
We could do only one median, but would prefer to make all of the medians in our district waterwise (on Eagle Rock Blvd, Colorado Blvd, Huntington Drive, and assorted medians downtown). Given the short turnaround time, I have not been able to extend the cost estimate to cover all of the medians.

In any case, when you consider the number of grassy medians we have in the City of Los Angeles, and the tremendous volume of imported water we use to maintain them, not to mention the cost of that water, transforming them into medians better suited for Southern California's semi-arid climate makes much sense.

Thank you for your consideration and have a wonderful Labor Day weekend.


Best,
 
Tricia Robbins
Planning Deputy
Office of Councilmember José Huizar,14th District 
200 N Spring Street, Room 465
Los Angeles, California 90012
Phone 213.473.7014, Fax 213.847.0680

And here is Ms. Robbins's discussion about reducing the project costs:

Yes, the figures do apply to one median within our district and the ballpark quote was obtained from the Bureau of Street Services and based on City Staff construction time. 

When the community developed the plan, they envisioned doing some volunteer work (MAC members are Landscape Architects, work with Northeast Trees and Tree People, are on the Neighborhood Council, and have other affiliations), obtaining trees through the City's million trees program, gaining planting assistance from Tree People, obtaining free mulch and similar materials from the Sanitation Dept, and working with the Los Angeles Conservation Corps (http://www.lacorps.org/ - their mission is to provide at-risk young adults and school-aged youth with job skills training, education and work experience with an emphasis on conservation and service projects that benefit the community). 

All of which is to say, I believe the actual figures could be significantly less.

The Councilmember has committed to finding the funds to make this demonstration project a reality, and between the City's in kind materials donation and Council office and community sweat equity, the grant would leverage public and other funds. 

Finally, while we also had Median Advisory Committee groups in El Sereno and Highland Park / Glassell Park, the one focusing on Eagle Rock was the one that coalesced and moved forward with producing plans first. It has always been the intention that the plans produced for the target median first be vetted by the City departments and implemented, so that the lessons learned in that process could be applied to the other area medians.

Best of all, based on the following statement from LADWP, significant savings may be realized by the City:

“In the LA area cool season grass uses about 50 inches of water per year. The cost of 1st tier water is currently $3.729 p/ HCF.   If you are going to remove turf, you may qualify for a rebate of $1.00 per square foot.”

Using my back of the envelope calculations the demonstration median is 80’ x 16’ which equals 1,280’. I’ can’t give you a definite translation into the above parameters, but at 50 inches of water per year for cool season grass, I’m sure it’s a significant savings.

Three proposals from Barry Lehrman: (1) exhibitions, (2) a symposium, and (3) K - 12 curriculum

Dear colleagues:

Here are three grant proposals from Barry Lehrman, Assistant Professor of Landscape Architecture at Cal Poly Pomona.  He is proposing:  (1) exhibitions on "aqueduct futures" at the LA City Hall Bridge Gallery, the Autry Museum, and the Eastern California Museum; (2) a symposium to be co-sponsored by Cal Poly Pomona, UCLA, and Pitzer College; and (3) a K - 12 curriculum project.

Best regards,
Michael




It is a pleasure to share the following ideas to expand impact of the public outreach abilities Aqueduct Futures Project and to initiate new Centennial endeavors.  Together they represent the holistic vision for the Aqueduct Centennial Project that was originally shared with Metabolic Studios, but they are each able to stand alone.  The proposal are: 1)  Aqueduct Futures Exhibition Fabrication, 2) Aqueduct Centennial Symposium, and 3) K-12 Aqueduct Curriculum

1) Aqueduct Futures Exhibition -  Autry Museum, LA City Hall Bridge Gallery, and Eastern California Museum
 $38,530 to $81,100    (labor, materials, and transportation of exhibition pieces to venues)

The exhibition will showcase the student's designs for the future of the Aqueduct and surrounding landscape at venues that get up to 24,000 visitors per month. The design of the exhibition will take place in Winter 2013 as part of the initial Metabolic Studio funding of the Aqueduct Futures Project. This proposal is to fabricate the installation. Material donations and in-kind sponsorships are also being sought which is reflected in the budget range - the low end assumes a majority of construction materials are donated.
 
The exhibition will include computer kiosks to access the Aqueduct Futures Web Portal (at each venue), information panels/banners (at each venue), and sculptural elements (at the Autry Museum) that  invite tactile exploration and interactive learning about the functioning of the aqueduct, water cycle, and environment.  Materials used will primarily be recycled materials with low water and environmental footprints.  Students will report on the life-cycle analysis for the fabrication that shares data on the carbon emissions, water footprint, and other environmental impacts of the exhibition and courses.
 
A public audience  is targeted, with components appropriate for k-12 students, design students, the public, and policy makers.  There are opportunities for workshops to promote awareness of water conservation methods and water issues in California, and to have school children design their own aqueduct as part of the exhibition.  The Autry Museum education department is excited by the opportunity to work with Cal Poly faculty and students to develop educational materials.  

See attached proposal for detailed budget and timeline of the exhibition.


2) Aqueduct Centennial Symposium - co-organized with UCLA's Institute for the Environment and Sustainability, Pitzer College's Conservancy for Southern California Sustainability
$80,800 - $123,900 (see attached description for budget details)
This symposium brings together the science, design, art, engineering, and policy perspectives on the future of water for Los Angeles to initiate crafting solutions to enable a resilient and adaptive future.  The aim is to cross-fertilize scholarship into adapting landscapes to the Anthropocene, and designing eco-technical systems for resilient cities.  Other Southern California institutions are welcome to join the steering committee.
Invited speakers (most have confirmed their interest) come from across the US and world to share the global context and lessons for our local issues. They provide a range of perspectives that balance between the technical and poetic aspects of creating resilient landscapes/adapting cities to climate change, and  between critical perspective on the cultural meanings of infrastructure and  societal values related to water.  These participants will have a range of rolls at the symposium, from being featured presenters, workshop facilitators, or showcase their design projects and artwork around the venue.

See attached for detailed budget and timeline of the symposium. Additional information will be shared with you before the September 5th Chora Council. 


3) K-12 Aqueduct Curriculum Project - School of Education and Integrative Studies/Department of Landscape Architecure
$44,600 (faculty time, materials, consultants, and supplies)

This project develops a range of k-12 lessons and activities about water and environmental education in collaboration with the School of Education and Integrative Studies. 

For Spring 2013, I propose offering an course where education students develop k-12 lesson designs and curriculum components.  Over the summer of 2013, a copy editor and consultants will edit the student projects and package them for distribution; design and launching AqueductCurriculum.edu. Fall 2013, hold events to provide professional development/training opportunities with the Aqueduct k-12 curriculum (targeting Pomona and LAUSD schools).

A website will be set up to disseminate the materials

The budget subtotal is $40,600,  $44,600 w/F&A. This budget includes 4WTUs for teaching the course, a research assistant over the spring and next summer, services of a copy editor and educational design consultants, and materials/supplies for the professional development/training events. 

The K-12 Aqueduct curriculum project can be expanded to other schools of education around Southern California with additional funding. 
Dear colleagues:

Here is a request from Melanie Winter, Director of the River Project, for a grant to support a proposed book which would put forward a "vision plan" for the Southern California watershed.

Best regards,
Michael



Book Proposal Summary
Elemental LA is a visually rich book anchored by hard science and lively dialogue, that looks at opportunities
to integrate and prioritize the natural cycles of water, soil, fire and air in urban planning and design for
true sustainability of the region. This visionary scope asserts that there is an illusion of permanence of
the existing grid and infrastructure, and that long-term success of Los Angeles depends on reshaping
that grid to promote the restoration and integration of natural processes with sustainable urban design,
indeed to think of ecosystem functions as critical infrastructure, while anticipating the need for resiliency
and local resource security in a climate change and post-peak oil world.
Ever since William Mulholland proclaimed “There it is – take it,” design and planning for the Los Angeles
region has omitted the role of ecosystem function in shaping and sustaining the land and life of the region.
This is true even of many “sustainable” visions for Los Angeles. Modern urban development in Los Angeles
has been predicated on the idea that resources can be extracted from increasingly distant locations, and
that the city itself should promote the automobile culture. This has had tremendous ecological and social
effects. Aquifer recharge zones were paved over, groundwater was depleted, fisheries and agriculture
extirpated, and even species extinctions have occurred. As the city has grown, so has its dependence
on imported water, with attendant impacts to distant communities and an awkward relationship with
agricultural districts also competing for water deliveries. The energy necessary to deliver and treat water,
as well as mimic compromised ecological functions, causes environmental impacts on a scale reaching
well beyond the metropolitan area.
The promise of mobility implicit in our freeway network has given way to the reality of congestion and
immobility. Neighborhoods are arguably physically and socially isolated, with the single-family housing
unit model of development turning residents inward rather than toward community gathering spaces.
In addition to severe ambient air pollution, freeway traffic directly affects the health of people living or
working near those roadways. The flow of consumer goods inland from the Ports of Los Angeles and
Long Beach exacerbates this effect and further compromises the livability of communities near goods
movement corridors.
Reestablishing watershed functions in Los Angeles, primarily the flooding and groundwater recharge
function of rivers and alluvial fans, is key to removing impacts and rethinking urban form for the future.
Floodplains are perfectly suited for agriculture and recreation, uses with the potential to provide food
security and outlets for the region’s youth. As the city reshapes itself with public transit and densification,
the time is ripe to require strategic, concurrent open space set-asides for each new development that can
provide critical ecosystem services. Such strategic densification, coupled with green streetscapes that
enhance pedestrian, bicycling, and public transit opportunities, will provide local water supply, reduce
air pollution, increase public health, and lead the public to ecological experiences of Los Angeles as yet
unknown to the region.
Elemental LA grounds these concepts with quantification of benefits and arresting visuals. The book format
is an edited volume, including an illustrated vision plan in the opening chapters, followed by discussion
by experts from a range of disciplines, including the sciences, economics, and social policy. The book
closes with a chapter responding to these discussions, and proposing a path towards implementation.
While the book targets planners, designers and policy-makers, it is written in language that is accessible
to the average reader or aficionado of Los Angeles.
2
Table of Contents
i. Acknowledgements
ii. Purpose
iii. Introduction
Part I: Elemental LA: An Ecological Los Angeles Vision Plan (30%)
1. Context
Brief ecological history of Los Angeles basin
Landscape change and impact on watershed processes
Population and economics
Changing practices
Urgency
2. A Vision Plan
Defining sustainability
A Vision Plan (with images to inspire the future)
Unique zones of watershed function
Ecological urbanism
Industry and economics
3. Models for Implementation
Urban growth boundaries
Floodplain buy-back and aquifer recharge protection zoning
Fuel conversion (soil and air quality)
Green chemistry
Investments in comprehensive public transit infrastructure
Global water consumption norms and conservation programs
Part II: Expert Responses: Feasibility and Implications (50%)
4. Resource Management
Hydrology and Geomorphology, Water Supply, Agriculture, Fisheries and Biota,
Waste and Raw Materials, Green Chemistry, Fire Ecology
5. Urban Development
Policy, Architecture, Real Estate, Finance, Social Ecology, Homeless Services,
Aging
6. Public Health
Water Quality, Air Quality, Vector Control, Sewage
7. Transportation
Mass transit, single-vehicle transit, goods movement
8. A Geomorphologist, Real Estate Developer and Public Health expert step into a bar…
Part III: Conclusion (20%)
8. Response to Commentary
9. Moving Forward
3
Budget
Preliminary Draft Document: September – December 2012 $30,000
Condense and organize topic list
Confirm list of specialists in all relevant fields
Inventory historic and existing documents, visions, and planning documents
Draft initial graphics
Execute Draft Document
Gather Contributor Feedback: January – April 2013 $24,000
Schedule meetings with specialist groups
Team meetings to process and organize input
Document Development: May – October 2013 $46,000
Storyboard layout
Document writing
Additional research based on contributor feedback
Develop tables, charts, and additional graphics
Document review, editing
Contributor Roundtable: November 2013 $14,000
Produce materials & presentation
Develop Agenda
Facilitator & video transcription
Catering
Document Refinement: December 2013 – May 2014 $36,000
Incorporate Roundtable Feedback
Team writing retreat
Final Document Edits
TOTAL $150,000
4
Team Bios
Jessica Hall
Jessica Hall is a registered landscape architect whose career has been defined by the planning and
design of watershed rehabilitation projects. In the non-profit, governmental, and consulting sectors, she
has sought to create projects that protect and enhance habitat, increase public access, and improve the
quality of life in diverse communities of Los Angeles. During her previous employment with organizations
such as North East Trees, the Santa Monica Bay Restoration Commission and Restoration Design Group,
her work included advocacy, project inception, grant writing and management, facilitation, field surveying,
as well as design and construction administration. She has been an itinerate graduate-level studio
lecturer of landscape design and natural processes at California State Polytechnic University, Pomona
since 2007. She is currently employed as a landscape architect at La Loma Development Company in
Pasadena, California. Jessica received a B.A. in Architecture from Princeton University in 1992 and a
Master of Landscape Architecture degree from California State Polytechnic University, Pomona in 2001.
Melanie Winter
Melanie Winter is the founder and director of The River Project, a non-profit organization dedicated to
advancing comprehensive watershed-based planning in Los Angeles. She has been involved in water
and land-use policy efforts for 16 years, serving on numerous local and statewide boards and advisory
committees. She organized a coalition of local groups that secured the land and $45 million in state funds
to build the Los Angeles River’s largest park: El Rio de Los Angeles State Park. Recently, she produced
a watershed management plan for the San Fernando Valley that is helping to guide local water resources
planning. That plan garnered the American Planning Associations “Innovation in Green Community
Planning” award in 2009. She is currently partnered with the LA Conservation Corps to provide on-going
recreational and educational expeditions on the L.A River. The River Project is currently partnered with
the LADWP and the City of Los Angeles to implement several of the projects identified in that plan,
including the Woodman Avenue Median Retrofit and Water LA – an project to engage homeowners in
rainwater harvesting and to make these practices legal in Los Angeles. Before founding The River Project
in 2000, Melanie was the Executive Director of Friends of the Los Angeles River where, among other
programs, she produced the River Though Downtown conference.
Francisco Dóñez
Francisco Dóñez is an environmental policy professional and educator. Extensively trained in engineering,
policy, and social science, he is well versed in the technical, social, and cultural aspects of environmental
problems. Currently a staff member at the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, he has also designed
and taught environmental studies courses at Pitzer College and the University of California, Berkeley.
Francisco completed his Ph.D. in the Energy and Resources Group at the University of California,
Berkeley in 2010. His dissertation examined a controversy over haze pollution in Big Bend National Park
in the 1990s as an illustration of the intersections between air pollution science and border environmental
politics. A native of Albuquerque, New Mexico, he received a B.S. in Mechanical Engineering from MIT in
1987, and an M.S. in Public Policy from Georgia Tech in 1996.
Joshua Link
Joshua Link is a registered landscape architect, urban designer, and graphic artist. He is a founding
partner of Ecotone Studios, a multi-disciplinary design practice based in northeast Los Angeles, where
he plays an integral role in the design and business direction of the firm. His work spans a broad scale
of projects, ranging from campuses and residential gardens to greenways and parks, including awardwinning
efforts such as the Los Angeles River Revitalization Master Plan, the Compton Creek Regional
Garden Park Master Plan, the Los Angeles State Historic Park competition, Vista Hermosa Natural Park
and the Ballona Creek Greenway Plan. Born and raised in Pasadena, California, at the base of the
San Gabriel Mountains, he developed a lifelong interest in wild places at an early age. His ecological
curiosity has evolved into a design philosophy rooted in reconnecting people to the places they inhabit.
He received a Bachelor of Landscape Architecture degree from California Polytechnic State University,
San Luis Obispo in 2006.

Grant proposal to address dust blowing and soil erosion in the Owens Valley

Dear colleagues:

Here is a proposal from Ms. Meredith McKenzie, an Urban and Regional Planning faculty member at Cal Poly Pomona who has just started an Urban Rivers Institute.  She is proposing a grant below to address the serious problems of dust blowing and soil erosion in the Owens Valley.

Best regards,
Michael



Sediment After-Life: A Cradle to Cradle Solution to Owens Valley Dust Environmental Hazards

OVERVIEW

All riverine and water conveyance systems carry two main components: water and sediment. Because of So California's current dam/debris basin system, sediment is trapped and must be periodically removed, where it is often transported to landfills for its after-life. Meanwhile, historic over-drafting of fresh water flows from the Owens River by LADWP, coupled with intensified drought conditions, has led to court-ordered directives to the City of Los Angeles for dust abatement in the Owens Valley to alleviate the erosion of top soil and increased health risks of valley fever among its residents, to name just two impacts.

The current system of water drafting and sediment build-up/removal perpetuates an open end system of use and disposal, rather than the closed end loop of the 'cradle to cradle' cycle that Mother Nature, especially through the hydrologic cycle, has used for eons.

PROJECT PARTNERS

This project affords an innovative, collaborative research project uniting the applied research expertise of the 'water initiative' at Cal Poly Pomona with the dust management program of the Los Angeles Dept of Water and Power, the wastewater sludge program of the Los Angeles Department of Sanitation, and the sediment management program of the Los Angeles County Flood Control District to create an innovative means of creating a productive post-riverine after-life of sediment particles and wastewater sludge as a ground cover spread (wet cake) to abate excessive dust in the Owens Valley. Informal discussions with top leadership within each of these agencies suggest their interest in pursuing such a project as a new means to manage 'waste' products while offering multi-benefits, including environmental protection, resource re-use, and workforce development.

PROJECT SUMMARY

The Sediment After-Life program will utilize sediment from Los Angeles County water storage basins through a blending of this silt with wastewater sludge from the City of Los Angeles, to create a 'wet cake' that can be spread on dust eroded areas within the Owens Valley. Phase I of this project will unite the three partners: Cal Poly, LA City and LA County, in an applied research project that will test various mixtures of these organic compoounds to find the right recipe for dust ground spreading. Phase II of this project will explore manufacturing and spreading options, with a specific focus on creating a new manufacturing facility (perhaps in the Owens Valley) that will produce the 'wet cake' for initial spreading in the Owens Valley and potential expansion as a spreading product for other dust-prone regions of the Southwest United States.

Utilizing faculty and students from the Colleges of Science (chemical analysis), Business (development of manufacturing technology), Agriculture (adaptive re-use through compounds that can act as a fertilizer as well as a ground cover), Engineering (analysis of sediment removal best practices) and Environmental Design (development of public outreach campaign, landscape palate and manufacturing center architecture), the Sediment After-Life project will offer students a multi-disciplinary learning experience that can result in the 'incubation' of the new manufacturing process lab on the Cal Poly campus.

BUDGET

The short time line for responding to the internal request for proposal precludes the submission of a full budget at this time; it is, however, projected that Phase I will require a minimum $250,000 commitment spread over 3 years to complete the research, development and testing of this concept which will include dedicated faculty research time, student internships, field trips, laboratory testing equipment, conference presentations, and related costs.

WHY THIS PROJECT IS EXCITING

One of the goals of the Owens Valley Centennial is to both celebrate the past but to also seek innovation for the future along this important water conveyance on which so many Southern Californians depend. The Sediment After-Life Project seeks to solve a persistent environmental issue - dust blowing and soil erosion - by 're-using' nature's own by-products at the core of a new solution. Moreover, by integrating this research with an entrepreneurial, manufacturing based business model, the project offers long-term sustainable benefits, including job creation and the exporting of 'wet cake' to other drought-stricken regions with similar dust problems.

Thank you for giving me the opportunity to submit this proposal. I have run it by Barry Lehrman who thinks it's a fabulous idea and consistent with his goals for the Aqueduct Futures project.

Two grant proposals: (1) Funding a "curator" and (2) urban hydration stations

Dear colleagues:

I am beginning the process of posting grant proposals for your consideration.  I'll begin with two proposals which I have played a role in instigating, followed by some other proposals which I have collected from others.

Best regards,
Michael


Proposal:  Fund a “curator” for the Los Angeles Aqueduct centenary

Source:  Michael Woo (after speaking to some of the other members of the Chora Cuuncil)

Potential partner(s):  City of Los Angeles or L.A. Department of Water and Power; Metropolitan Water District

Rationale:  It is now abundantly clear that there will be many activities taking place, from the Owens Valley to Los Angeles,, marking the centenary of the Los Angeles Aqueduct.  What appears to be missing (as frequently happens in Southern California) is a unifying framework or a communications network to enable the many disparate audiences for the Aqueduct centenary to have a sense of the larger picture and to be aware of the range of Aqueduct-related activities going on.

For this reason, a grant to fund one or more individuals to “curate” the diverse Aqueduct centenary-related activities could have a tangible effect on public awareness of the centenary and would increase the value of the separate centenary-related projects.

LADWP may be limiting its coordination role to centenary-related activities which it directly controls.

The main benefit of event coordination and improved communications is the magnification of the significance of the Aqueduct centenary.  In theory, a curator of the Aqueduct centenary, supported by a website, social media, and printed materials, could amplify the significance of the centenary, especially if the curator’s work effectively links and expands the audiences which may be aware of separate events but not the larger meaning of the centenary.


Proposal:  Urban hydration stations

Source:  Dr. Catherine Howells, College of Urban and Public Affairs, Portland State University, and Michael Woo, Dean of the College of Environmental Design, Cal Poly Pomona

Potential partner(s): Global Tap (for-profit social enterprise); IDEO (innovative design consulting firm)

Rationale:  In a frequently dry place such as Southern California, access to water for pedestrians, bicycle riders, and other members of the public would be a much-appreciated amenity (and public service).  Other American cities such as Portland, Oregon, are known for public drinking fountains known as “Benson Bubblers” which provide sidewalk-level public access to a constantly flowing source of drinking water.

In Southern California, where water is less abundant than in Portland, free flowing water probably sends the wrong message about water consumption at a time when water conservation should be emphasized.   Instead of free flowing water, a modern hydration system could provide the public with access to water without encouraging wasteful use of water.  And, by encouraging consumers to drink water from re-usable water bottles (instead of disposable single-use bottled water) by making it easy and convenient to re-fill the bottles, these hydration systems would promote more sustainable attitudes towards water consumption

Use of grant funds to design, install, and operate a limited number of hydration systems in public places would be a relatively inexpensive way to create some new urban landmarks in the Los Angeles area which also serves an important public need and sends a message about water conservation at the same time.  To reinforce the connection to the Aqueduct centenary, it may be a good idea to install the hydration stations in easily recognizable “corridors.”

Here is a link to an article explaining the origin of the concept of urban hydration stations as developed by an architect in Chicago who became aware of the global crisis of access to drinking water and hooked up with IDEO, the innovative design consulting firm:


Here is a link to a San Francisco experiment with “environmentally friendly water filling stations”:

  
The design shown in the photograph is not very elegant, but it conveys the basic idea:  put a piece of infrastructure on the sidewalk which members of the public could use to refill water bottles (and perhaps also use for other hydration purposes, such as spraying a mist of cool water on your head, enable overheated kids to dip their feet in cool water on a hot day, or providing drinking water for a dog out for a walk).

To improve the design, a design competition could be sponsored to solicit design ideas from practitioners and students.

Cost:  $2,875.95 per unit (water bottle filler only); $3,675.95 per unit (water bottle filler with attached fountain).  Source of cost estimates: 


It is possible that the cost per unit would decline if multiple units were ordered at the same time.